Rated 4.7/5.0
based on 31 reviewsShowing 16–30 of 31 reviews
AN
anti-spasti
By far the best tool to learn about bitcoin addresses and transactions. It is very easy even if some people might think it is complicated at first, if you use it once - after that you understand more about bitcoin than with any other tool. It is very secure as the new updates are focused on secure payments even more. When creating and handling Bitcoin addresses, signatures, transactions, and keys, we want to avoid outside influence as much as possible. We have basically two ways to create a BIP39 seed with seedsigner hardware: 1) Dice and 2) Image/Photo. Both methods are good & established entropy sources (bitcoin addresses are just big random numbers) as they do not depend on special hardware. The seedsigner has it all covered.
View full review OK
okin
SeedSigner - The Stateless Transaction Signing Device for the Masses! It's Magic!
SeedSigner is definitely my favourite Bitcoin tool to use. Most would call it a Hardware Wallet, but I prefer calling it a Stateless Transaction Signing Device, unlike others which could be said to be Private Key Storage Devices. You might be wondering “What’s the difference?” and this is where we’ll start the review. I was lucky enough to get the parts of my amazing SeedSigner sent to me via normal snail mail all the way from Europe as I couldn’t get them in my country. This allowed me to have the full experience of assembling the parts myself, downloading; verifying that download & flashing the SD Card, plugging the device into a wall charger (never into a computer) & then seeing that SeedSigner splash screen flip on. Another amazing thing that blew my mind was that I got to pay for the parts using Bitcoin over the Lightning Network too. Attempting to describe it will never do that moment justice, but luckily you can experience it for yourself since SeedSigner made it their mission to, said best by them, “SeedSigner offers anyone the opportunity to build a verifiably air-gapped, stateless Bitcoin signing device using inexpensive, publicly available hardware components”. The awesome thing is that with these parts normally costing under $50 it is actually accessible to many Africans like myself & it having a Stateless component makes it ideal for use by multiple people, like with a normal Pen, which is the signing device we’re used to. SeedSigner has a slew of amazing features but I "quickly" want to direct you to my favourite ones that blew me away as I was setting up Cold Storage Wallets for my Nieces & Nephews with it: It allows you to enter both a 12 or 24 word seed which you have created on another device, using other software like BlueWallet or Sparrow Wallet for instance. A unique feature of SeedSigner is that you can create a seed & then add a BIP39 Passphrase, which is like a password you can create yourself, after the fact to further secure your Bitcoin Wallet. When you create a seed, the SeedSigner gives you a fingerprint which is associated with that seed & makes it easier for you to identify for yourself if you have multiple seeds (Note: This fingerprint isn’t entered anywhere & is just for your own convenience). This means that if you create a seed you will have a specific fingerprint & then after you add the BIP39 Passphrase the fingerprint will change to a different one. Meaning you could essentially use a single seed (12 or 24 words) and then create an infinite amount of wallets with different passphrase which are all independent of each other with that same seed. That’s magic! When you create a seed it isn’t just randomly given to you without you having any way to influence it like with many other wallets & signing devices. With SeedSigner you have a few options to create your entropy. You can take a picture or roll dice, for instance. The dice has a high umber of rolls you need to do, 50 rolls for a 12 word seed & 99 rolls for a 24 word seed. However, the picture option is what I found interesting as a feature, as you can literally take a picture of something nobody else could guess & then have your seed derived from that randomness. Again, Magic! I do believe one of the more serious & unique tools that comes with the SeedSigner is that you can enter all 11 or 23 words of your seed & then have it calculate your 12th or 24th word for you. This allows you to check that the final word of your seed was generated correctly by the checksum method which basically generates the last word from the previous words. Yes, it sounded as wild to me as it probably sounds to you now. lol Another favourite feature of mine is that you can export the xpub of your seed & then import it into something like BlueWallet as a watch-only wallet. This feature means that I can create a seed, export it as a watch-only wallet, use that wallet to receive any payments for my goods & services, or even donations, but never risk my funds being taken from me without access to my SeedSigner to sign the partial Bitcoin transaction. When you go to sign it, it looks really cool since the QR Code keeps changing & you literally have to scan about 100 iterations of that change & then confirm & broadcast the signed transaction in order to spend those Satsoshis. That is immensely secure for me & makes me feel a lot safer than using a Hot wallet, even though it’s partially hot I guess. Okay, that last one was a bit long, but necessary to drive home that this is definitely a device I believe every Bitcoin Enthusiast, Educator & Stacker needs to at least try out once. Plus the fact that it’s truly stateless in that it doesn’t save any of the seeds entered onto it in a session, it wipes itself clean every time it switches off & then on, means a person could onboard an entire Village, Community, School, Organisation or any amount of people without fear of leaking the information to the next person to use it. Like using a pen to write an essay & then passing the pen onto the next person to use, the words previously written don’t move with the pen & the next person writes what they want with it, which once again only stays with the writer & not the pen as it moves on. So in closing, it feels & acts like Magic!
View full review GO
gobrrr_me
Innovative & Optimized for deep cold storage
SeedSigner enables anyone to build an airgapped Bitcoin signing device using only off the shelf hardware. All that’s needed is a Raspberry Pi Zero, LCD-Display hat, a Pi-Cam and GPIO headers. Building the device yourself has many advantages over buying one, from avoiding crm databases of hww manufacturers, to being able to do it even in adverse enviroments. You can even 3D-print your own enclosure, the files and the Software are open-source. The device is completely airgapped, has no Wi-Fi or Bluetooth whatsoever and the SD-card is only used to run the SeedSigner software. Communication with coordinator software works via QR codes and the integrated camera. From animated QRs for sharing xpubs, to an entirely new standard, the SeedQR Standard, which enables the transcription of a seed phrase to an encrypted QR format only readable by SeedSigner (and Blockstream Jade), which can then be imported into SeedSigner. The stateless nature of SeedSigner makes sure no sensitive information is ever stored on the device, as it wipes all memory when the power is cut. No info can be leaked, not even if the device is stolen. This is why the camera and QR codes play such a big role: re-entering the seed every time would be very tedious; but if the seed can be stored and loaded externally relatively easily, it results in a security model that is quite unique compared to classic hardware wallets. The SeedSinger software has a beautiful UI/UX which is easy to get into, but hard to master, as it offers a plethora of options for advanced setups like multisig, while also being easy to use for single sig cold storage. One thing that stands out the most, in my opinion, is the fact that the UI was designed to make you understand what you’re doing here. I learned so much by just using SeedSigner, you really should give it a try. Overall, SeedSigner is the most innovative Bitcoin signing device I have seen in my lifetime and I can highly recommend it to anyone who wants to level up their Bitcoin security.
View full review RA
radev777
The cheaper way to hodl your crypto in secure way! Awesome!
So, a month ago, I was trying to find out which hardware wallet should I buy. My conditions were simple; it had to be open-source and I had to make the purchase in the most private way possible. My only option was to buy BitBox 1, but it happens to be old, deprecated and their developers aren't known for being privacy seekers, which really underwhelmed me. My only choice was to purchase a hardware wallet outside my country using a poste restante, which I didn't want to do for personal reasons. But, then dkbit98 suggested something I hadn't thought of; do the job with a Pi. And so I did. I bought a RPi Zero, a camera, a little screen and a few other stuff, and built a SeedSigner; an air-gapped hardware wallet signing device, which takes security into the next level. I like the camera, because I can scan the PSBT from your computer's monitor. Its super easy to use and secure! I Like it and I recommend it. In summary: Pros: Open source, github page: https://github.com/SeedSigner/seedsigner Air-gapped Relatively cheap ($50$100) Separation between private key storage and signing Can be bought anonymously (without KYC, AOPP etc.) Cons: Little hard setup Experimental software; the project is, well from what I can judge, in an early stage Works only with BlueWallet, Nunchuk, Sparrow, Specter Desktop It's forcing you to generate the entropy yourself SeedSigner aims to give a solution to one problem; the cost and complexity of multi-sig usage. However, at the same time, it can be used for single-sig setups, lowering the cost of your "hot" storage as well. There's nothing saved inside the SD card, besides your settings which is optional, therefore there's less danger for funds' loss. When you shut down SeedSigner, it erases the seeds; they're meant to be kept temporarily in memory and you have to import the seed on each startup. And that's basically one of the features that makes SeedSigner differentiate. Feature Highlights: Calculate word 12/24 of a BIP39 seed phrase Create a 24-word BIP39 seed phrase with 99 dice rolls Create a 24-word BIP39 seed phrase by taking a digital photo Temporarily store up to 3 seed phrases while device is powered Guided interface to manually create a SeedQR for instant input (demo video here) BIP39 passphrase / word 25 support Native Segwit Multisig XPUB generation w/ QR display Scan and parse transaction data from animated QR codes Sign transactions & transfer XPUB data using animated QR codes (demo video here) Live preview during photo-to-seed and QR scanning UX Optimized seed word entry interface Support for Bitcoin Mainnet & Testnet Support for custom user-defined derivation paths On-demand receive address verification User-configurable QR code display density Responsive, event-driven user interface
View full review LO
loke43tre
Una billetera infravalorada.
Había leído que seedsigner tenía algunas ventajas que otras carteras no tenían, así que decidí probarlo. Las ventajas son que la billetera es de código abierto y tiene un espacio de aire. También es relativamente más barato que algunos de los otros grandes nombres de la industria. Las desventajas son que es mucho más difícil de configurar que algunas de las otras marcas populares. Vi algunos videos y leí varios artículos, pero aún tuve problemas. Con esta billetera, básicamente la está construyendo usted mismo y originando sus propias palabras clave, etc. Para el principiante, creo que esto es demasiado para ellos. Incluso para mí, que tengo varias billeteras de almacenamiento en frío, encontré esto difícil y lento. Si eres muy técnico, entonces esto puede no ser un problema. \ En general, diría que hay billeteras más fáciles de usar en el mercado que parecen ser igual de seguras.
View full review BO
bobahodl
Underrated Hardware Wallet
SeedSigner is my favorite physical wallet in the entire space. It's got a great user interface, compatible with great wallets, and something you can build from locally sourced parts. The best part for me? It's stateless. It retains no memory once it's powered off. You can create as many single, multi sig wallets in this wifi-bluetooth-less signing device! The only bad thing is the lack of raspberry pis available - else I'd gift this to all of my friends & family.
View full review HE
hernan22lobo
Una gran idea, producto 100% bitcoiner.
En la utilizacion de este dispositivo podes experimentar la verdadera sensación de ser bitcoiner, o intentar serlo. Es una idea maravillosa, en la quien adquiere esta dispositivo realiza la construccion del mismo. En realidad es un firmante de semillas, que parece una billetera comun, pero no lo es. Este dispositivo sirve para firma de Bitcoin sin estado. Las funciones que mas me gustan son la maxima seguridad de tus claves y que este dispositivo no pueda conectarse ni por WiFi o Bluetooth. La idea es que de manera distinta puedas conectar por un código QR bidireccional, que lees tanto con la camara del dispositivo como la de la PC. Todo lo que encierra esta idea de como cuidar tus llaves parece dificil, pero en realidad no lo es tanto, aunque no lo recomiendo a principiantes. A modo de sugerencia, me gustaria que puedan elaborar la idea de un software propio para poder utilizar el dispositivo, igual los felicito por tan gran idea de como cuidar nuestros fondos.
View full review EX
extracarecleanbg
Air-gapped signing device
I like that you can buy the parts buy yourself and you DON'T TRUST VERIFY. It's very cheap about 50$. You can do multisig very easy and for low money. The problem is that Raspberry Pi zero are hard to find on market. The second problem - you need to bring the QRcode with device, device do not hold seeds on it. Another + is Its very secure, air-gapped environment for private key generation.
View full review DR
DrunkPlato
The Ultimate Tool for Bitcoiners that are serious about protecting their Private Keys
"The Seed Signer takes Bitcoin self-custody to a pathological level". I can't remember who said it, but I heard a guest say something like this on a BTC Sessions' podcast once, and it stuck. The Seed Signer really is the ultimate device for any Bitcoiner who takes self-custody seriously. I see that some people say it's not for beginners, but I'm not sure this is always true. I think a beginner can learn so much about Bitcoin just by learning how to use one of these, and the official documentation is top-tier. Easy to ready and follow. It is an advanced tool, but learning how to use one of these will teach you so much about how Bitcoin works, and it will give you the confidence of knowing that you can secure or move your funds with complete privacy by keeping your private keys offline. I'd really recommend one of these to anyone serious about Bitcoin.
View full review CL
clouder
Not a cold storage wallet for beginners.
I had read that seedsigner had some advantages that other wallets did not so decided to give it a try. The pro's are that the wallet is open source and air gapped. It is also relatively cheaper than some of the other big names in the industry. The cons are that it is much more difficult to set up than some of the other popular brands. I watched a few videos and read multiple articles but still struggled. With this wallet, you are basically building it yourself and originating your own key words, etc. For the beginner, I think that this is just to much for them. Even for myself who owns several cold storage wallets, I found this difficult and time consuming. If you are very techy, than this may not be an issue. \ Overall, I would say that there are more user friendly wallets on the market that seems to be just as secure.
View full review LA
lacazan
The best cold wallet by far
This is a great idea come true. That everyone can build their own cold wallet at home by buying parts seems to me the only way to get a reliable device. It certainly takes time to understand the device, wrestle with 3D printing, soldering and software installation, but the result is worth it. I understand it's not for everyone but at the end of the day you have the assurance that the keys generated are reliable and your funds are safe. The biggest drawback is the shortage of Raspberry Pi Zero boards. To solve this problem developers are already looking for an alternative on ESP32 boards. The future is promising. Translated with www.DeepL.com/Translator (free version)
View full review ZA
zamyatin
The real way to cold store your bitcoin.
SeedSigner offers the ability to combine generic components found almost anywhere in the world with brilliant design and free, open-source software. Although the setup and use is a steep learning curve, this is for someone wanting to understand more about how to actually own bitcoin. After creating an air-gapped bitcoin address the user can feel safe in the knowledge that the bitcoin they store on this address is not accessible by anyone else and is their sole responsibility. Therefore, I would qualify that this is not for the faint-hearted. I would recommend that this is part of a plethora of wallets and storage devices that you are using to distribute the risk on your ownership of bitcoin. The self stated goal of SeedSigner is to lower the cost and complexity of Bitcoin multi-signature wallet use. I believe it accomplishes this goal. The cost for my setup was $100.00 per pre-built device but if these were built from singular components the cost would be much less, especially if the case was 3D printed. The device allows output of a manually drawn QR code and a 12 or 24 word seed phrase. The complexity comes from having to understand why the steps are in place to ensure the device is air-gapped, and therefore no private keys ever leave the device and are not present on the device when power is removed. The device needs the Seedsigner software, as well as an SD card on which to install. To ensure proper use of the device it is worth purchasing a external power supply such as a small battery bank and USB-C cable. The only other aspect to the setup is having a computer with a bitcoin wallet software such as Sparrow to use as a 'watch-only' wallet so you can easily view how much bitcoin is on the address without anyone having access to the funds. Overall, using SeedSigner is a great experience to help get into Bitcoin or to take a deeper dive if you have never cold-stored your bitcoin. I would recommend getting this and taking at least some of your fund off exchanges or even mobile wallets to spread and reduce risk.
View full review GR
Griffenator99
SEED SIGNER ROCKS
Ordered an Assembly kit from seed signer. Was a bit of a learning curve putting together. But once set up was blown away by the concept. Good cheap little Bitcoin only signing device.
View full review JE
jerek31
Works great and cheap!
Most fun and innovative out there. It's pretty wild to build your own seed signer. Works great and cheap!
View full review CK
ckj
I would say best and cheap offline, air-gapped Bitcoin transaction signing device.
When I was looking for a cheap offline, air-gapped Bitcoin transaction signing device I saw about speed signer . I was always loose my bitcoin wallet key but now I have safe way to keep it safe Good things : • It is very cheap.(which made me to buy it) • it has Quick Installation. • the best part is we can make our own case for it. Bad things: Nothing I saw bad in this product after using it.
View full review 