RE
reed
Swan the company is great! Buying and withdrawing from them them is not so great.
First let me say that the team at Swan Bitcoin is incredible! This is a bitcoin only company that truly understands the mission we are on to bring freedom money to the citizens of earth. Their focus on education and onboarding new bitcoiners is top notch and I 100% agree with their mission. They also have a solid Dollar Cost Averaging (DCA) program that is an excellent place for anyone to start on their bitcoin journey and have no withdrawal fees, which is especially nice in high fee environments. However. There are some things about Swan that drive me a little bit crazy and I really hope that they start focusing on how to fix these things. Very intense KYC process for new customers. I gifted bitcoin this past Christmas to a lot of my family members through Swan and many were very put off by the level of information they needed to provide including facial scans, IDs and other documentation. It led to some embarrassing conversations with people who know that I am a privacy advocate as well. I know that this may be par for the course these days, but it was not like this when I signed up at Swan a couple of years ago. Long bitcoin lock-up period. Buying from Swan is pretty easy and it's nice that you can instantly buy bitcoin from them without needing to wait for your ACH to clear. However, for purchases over $2500 they require a 30 day locking period! That is insane. I know that they need to protect themselves from charge backs, but I have NEVER seen a lock up period this long before. Even for purchases less than $2500, its still 10 days! This is in stark contrast to CashApp who allow for instant withdrawals. Complicated to Withdraw. Considering they promote themselves as an exchange who strongly encourages customers to withdraw their bitcoin into self-custody, they make it very difficult. First off, its hard to even find where on the site you go to withdraw. Then, rather than just pasting in a bitcoin address and sending off your coins, the process goes something like this: 1) register a bitcoin withdraw address so they can verify that its a real bitcoin address (i.e., not a lightning invoice or a BCH address or something) and give it a name of some kind, 2) Select that address as your withdraw location. 3) Submit the bitcoin withdraw and type your 2FA. 4) Go to your email and click a link to confirm that you wanted withdraw the bitcoin. Maybe that doesn't sound that bad, but literally every time I withdraw I need to register another bitcoin address, name it the same thing again, but maybe with like a # at the end of it and I need to go back and forth to my email to log in, then my 2FA to withdraw, then again to my email to withdraw. Its actually quite annoying to me in comparison to other exchanges. Also automatic withdrawals either encourage address reuse, or require you to enter a lot of addresses. Plus, you still need to see the email and click the link within a certain time period or the automatic withdraw won't happen... not so automatic after all. High Fees. This honestly doesn't really bother me that much when you consider that this is how they make their money. They don't use shitcoins and they don't rehypothecate so they need to make money somewhere and I honestly don't have that much of an issue paying fees to bitcoin only companies. However, when you consider some of the above points, it is just that much harder to stack with Swan when you know you are also paying a premium to buy from them. Overall Swan is doing an excellent job of surviving as a bitcoin only exchange and I really hope that they succeed. I still love Swan despite some of these drawbacks (which are all really quite fixable IMHO), but if you are hoping for an awesome buying and withdrawing experience, you really aren't going to get it from Swan at this time.